Private Foundations and Tax Deductions: Maximizing the Impact of Your Contributions
Establishing a private foundation is a powerful way to create a lasting charitable legacy. To truly maximize the impact of your contributions, however, it's essential to understand the tax implications involved. With careful planning and a clear understanding of the rules, you can optimize the benefits of your donations while staying fully compliant with tax regulations.
Eligible Assets for Donation
Private foundations offer great flexibility when it comes to the types of assets they can accept. Donors can contribute a wide range of assets, such as cash, publicly traded securities, ETFs, mutual funds, closely held non-publicly traded business stock, LLC or LP interests, cryptocurrencies, life insurance policies, artwork, collectibles, and real estate. While this flexibility allows for creative giving strategies, not all assets are treated equally under tax laws. The tax treatment varies significantly depending on the type of asset donated, making it essential to plan accordingly to maximize your deductions.
Charitable Deduction Limits
When you donate to a private foundation and plan to take an itemized charitable deduction on your personal income tax return, there are limits to keep in mind. For cash donations, you can generally deduct up to 30% of your adjusted gross income (AGI). For non-cash donations, like real estate or publicly traded securities, the limit is 20% of your AGI.
If your donations exceed these limits in a given tax year, you don’t lose the ability to deduct the excess contributions. Instead, the IRS allows you to carry forward the unused portion of your donation for up to five subsequent years, subject to the same AGI limits in those years. By carefully timing your contributions and understanding these deduction limits, you can maximize the tax benefits of your charitable giving over time.
Deductible Value of Donations
Donating appreciated property can provide significant tax benefits, but the rules for claiming deductions differ greatly depending on whether the donation is made to a public charity or a private foundation.
When donating appreciated assets to public charities, you can typically deduct the fair market value (FMV) of the asset, provided you've held it for more than one year. This applies to a variety of assets, such as publicly traded securities, real estate, and other long-term capital gain property. However, there are exceptions to this rule, depending on the type of asset and its use by the charity.
When donating appreciated assets to private foundations, the rules are generally more restrictive. For non-cash assets like closely held business stock, real estate, cryptocurrency, or collectibles, the deduction is typically limited to the lesser of the asset's cost basis (the original value or purchase price) or FMV. This distinction is important because it can lead to a significantly lower deduction than what would be available for donations to public charities.
However, donations of publicly traded securities to private foundations are an important exception to this rule. In these cases, you are typically allowed to deduct the full FMV of the publicly traded securities, even when donating to a private foundation. This makes donations of publicly traded securities one of the most tax-efficient ways to contribute to a private foundation.
Since publicly traded securities are highly liquid and have readily available market valuations, the IRS permits deductions at FMV, making them far more advantageous compared to other types of appreciated property that may be limited to cost basis deductions. Donating publicly traded securities not only enables you to avoid paying capital gains taxes on the appreciation, but it also allows for a substantial deduction—at FMV—which maximizes your charitable impact.
Types of Assets Subject to the Cost Basis Limitation for Private Foundations:
1. Closely Held Stock: Donations of stock in privately held companies are subject to the cost basis or FMV limit, whichever is lower. This can result in a smaller deduction compared to publicly traded stock donations, which are generally deductible at FMV.
2. Real Estate: For real estate donations, the cost basis or FMV rule applies, meaning if the property has appreciated substantially, the deductible amount for private foundations may be far less than the FMV.
3. Cryptocurrency: As with other non-publicly traded assets, donations of cryptocurrency to private foundations are typically capped at the cost basis, while donations to public charities may allow a deduction at FMV.
4. Collectibles and tangible property: Donations of art, antiques or other similar assets are also subject to the cost basis or FMV limit, potentially resulting in a lower tax benefit.
Unrelated Business Income and Tax (UBIT)
When donating assets like private business interests, private equity holdings, or other similar investments, private foundations must carefully consider the potential for additional tax exposure through unrelated business income tax (UBIT). UBIT is triggered when a private foundation earns income from a business activity that is not substantially related to its exempt purpose. For example, if the foundation receives a donation of a business interest or private equity holding that continues to generate operational income, that income is considered unrelated to the foundation's charitable activities and is therefore subject to UBIT.
This tax is levied at standard corporate rates and can significantly increase the foundation’s overall tax liability, beyond the 1.39% excise tax on net investment income. If the business interest produces steady revenue, UBIT can become an ongoing burden, reducing the net benefit of the donation over time. Foundations must assess not only the immediate tax consequences but also the long-term impact of holding such assets, as consistent generation of business income could lead to recurring UBIT, potentially diminishing the value of the donated assets.
Documentation Requirements
Proper documentation is key when making non-cash donations to a private foundation. If your donation exceeds $5,000, a qualified appraisal is required to substantiate the deduction, and if the donation is valued over $500,000, a copy of the appraisal must be attached to your tax return. Failing to comply with these requirements can result in disallowed deductions, so it's vital to ensure that all paperwork is in order before filing.
Conclusion
Donating to a private foundation offers tremendous flexibility and the opportunity to create a long-term charitable impact. However, the tax rules surrounding these donations can be complex and challenging to navigate. By understanding key issues such as charitable deduction limits and asset valuation, you can optimize your tax benefits while supporting the causes that matter most to you. Contributing publicly traded securities to a private foundation is a particularly tax-efficient strategy, allowing you to maximize your deduction by using the FMV, while avoiding capital gains taxes
Seeking expert guidance? We're here to help!
At CPA KPA, we're passionate about magnifying the positive impact of foundations. Feel free to reach out to us anytime at 888-402-1780 for a complimentary and obligation-free conversation. You can also conveniently submit your questions and inquiries through our contact page. Let's connect today and explore how we can help your foundation have a lasting and meaningful impact!
